Like turow, grisham realizes that the most powerful argument against the death penalty is that it kills the innocent as well as the guilty, a case that he makes simply by. The dutton us edition of the innocent includes the exclusive short story the rise and fall of super d featuring myron bolitar. Steve is on trial for a being a possible accomplice to a murder. The guilty innocent is narrated by shannon adamcik, mother of torey, one of the accused boys. Obrien and wanted to thank her for her help but she just ignored him. Jerry sandusky is probably an innocent man, not a monster. This shows how steve finds out how he is really being judged by the jury even when the law says that you are innocent before proven guilty. It takes readers behind the scenes of a trial where prosecutors cared more about public opinion than truth, defense attorneys, who had never argued a murder case, were in over their heads, and a young boys life hung in the balance.
The conversations were all short and pointless, just polite acknowledgments or talk about ball games. But in the close confines of the bus there was no such thing as a silenced gun. I give monster a rate of 5 stars because this book is such an amazing book. Steves defense attorney, who does not know if he is guilty or innocent, but still tries her best to defend him sandra pertocelli the assistant district attorney who prosecute steve and king, labeling them monsters to the jury. Steve harmon guilty or innocent monster by walter dean myers. Steve s defense attorney, who does not know if he is guilty or innocent, but still tries her best to defend him sandra pertocelli the assistant district attorney who prosecute steve and king, labeling them monsters to the jury. For the first time, steve is forced to think about who he is as he faces prison, where he may spend all the tomorrows of his life. Although steve is adamant about defending his own innocence. Is steve really a monster in walter dean myers novel. Is steve an accomplice to murder or an innocent kid. The quote also indicates that she is trying to encourage steve to be the best he can to impress the jury and act as innocent as he can in order to win the case. After serving 18 years of his sentence, steven was found innocent and wrongfully accused. At this point it shows that steve s attorney had a lot of doubt about steve being jollity or not. The book monster by walter dean myers relates to my life and others today because in the book steve conformed to societys expectations and was a sheep to his acquaintances, which relates to me a fair while ago, because not to long ago i followed my friends and did what they did even though sometimes it wasnt the right thing to do.
However, i suppose it could be argued that this is not an accurate ruling. At the end of monster, my students write a five paragraph essay about their perspective on the innocence of steve harmon. Monster book by walter dean myers free essay example. Monster study guide contains a biography of walter dean myers, literature. Steve is on trial for allegedly being the lookout in a serious crime that involved robbery and murder. Guilty or not guilty graphic organizer is suitable for 4th 8th grade. After that statement he looked over to his attorney ms. According to the book monster, by myers, steve harmon is found innocent. Definitions and examples of 301 literary terms and devices. Are these feelings of being a monster based on the truth that he did passively signal the allclear to the robbers, and thereby he has blood on his hands.
Just writing in his journal isnt cutting it, so he. It was nominated for the 1999 national book award for young peoples literature, won the michael l. This changed steves life forever, because he would not spend his life in jail. Though walter dean myers young adult novel monster certainly does raise questions about choices, meyers also creates a great deal sympathy in. Printz award, monster was also recognized as a coretta scott king award honor book and national book award finalist. Though walter dean myers young adult novel monster certainly does raise questions about choices, meyers also creates a great deal sympathy in the readers for the protagonist steve harmon. And like shakespeares hamlet, the answer means life or death. Is obriens coaching intended to hide steves guilty feelings from the jury. Monster book report in monster, by walter dean myers, the reader learns from steve harmons experiences that sometimes guilt or innocence of a person might not be determined by solid evidence but by onlookers opinions and interpretation of the crime. The book opens with a warning from our narrator not to let anybody hear you crying cry at night. James king, osvaldo cruz, and freddy alou made up a few of the tough guys steve swapped dialogue with on occasion.
During my undergrad, i took a couple of philosophy courses that dealt with morals, ethics, utility, the greater good, etc. This book falls under the theme of stories that expose limits. Thats what prosecutor petrocelli calls him, and he cant help but dwell on it. Oct 28, 2012 the guilty innocent is narrated by shannon adamcik, mother of torey, one of the accused boys. Steve harmons experiences that sometimes guilt or innocence of a person might not be determined. Get everything you need to know about steve harmon in monster. As stated in the quote i think to get used to this i will have to give up what i think is real p. Jan 07, 2016 in 1985, avery was convicted of raping a woman in manitowoc county in wisconsin. The high drama in this dialoguedriven story will appeal to even reluctant readers. The monster in walter dean myers monster 879 words. The suppressor can was spun on as tight as it would go. Had he been in the drugstore on the day of the murder.
Readers are invested in learning about the crime, the evidence, the testimony, and the other teens involved in order to find out if steve is innocent or guilty. Smashwords the guilty innocent a book by shannon adamcik. Apr 27, 2009 the book monster by walter dean myers, is about teenager steve harmon who has a gift for screen play writing. Jerry sandusky is probably an innocent man, not a monster, claims controversial, wellresearched new book memory warp. Were you ever judged guilty before given a chance to prove yourself. If steve is found guilty of felony murder, hes looking at twentyfive years to life in prison. Monster by walter dean myers book report sample pdf.
Steve is guilty because he failed to stop the robbery as the lookouthad he done his job, nesbitt might still be alive. He admits that he is not a bad person which shows that he has grown through the past weeks. He is now beginning to realize that the case is a matter of his life and death and he might actually end up on death row. Has he betrayed parents, friends, teachers and his own hugely promising future in the blink of an eye. Steve is pretty freaked out, in need of a way to deal with both the trial and the nastiness surrounding him in prison. The cell also shows his involvment and how seriou his crime was. In the following quote you have to believe in yourselfp. Steve shows he has low selfesteem through out the story, he believes that he will lose the case and end up in prison for life. Opening statement we think that steve harmon is innocent because there is not enough evidence to prove he is guilty, he is very certain and stuck with trying to prove that that he was not there when the crime was committed and finally because. Whether or not steve is innocent is the big hook in this story.
Nov 07, 2007 do you agree that steve harmon is guilty or not for the crime why or why not. Or is he trapped in a rigged cycle from which kids like him rarely escape. While in prison, steve put his time to good use and wrote a play word for word based on his trial. Monster is a young adult drama novel by american author walter dean myers and was published by harpercollins in 1999. He refers to the other robbery participants as acquaintances whom he hardly talked with at all. Avery was freed and went on to live a free mans life, until 2007, when averys nephew and steven were convicted of murdering photographer teresa halbach, according to abc. Texts such as these encourage readers to interact with the text and with one another by employing a variety of devices, among them ambiguity campbell 1 because it is told through the eyes of steve himself, the plot can be difficult to. As for king, she says, hes guilty because he hangs out with the wrong kind of dudes and, as a result, nesbitt is dead. The story is written in screenplay format, due to steves passion for filmmaking, along.
The girl shifted her book a bit, letting the wash from the overhead light hit the page more fully. Grab some popcorn, and well settle down and munch on a few of them. Fred steese, who spent two decades in prison, after he was pardoned in november. Guilty or not guilty graphic organizer for 4th 8th. In monster, by walter dean myers, the reader learns from.
Pettrocelli concludes by attacking steve again, saying hes guilty no matter how innocent he may think. Guilty or innocent, steve becomes a pawn in the hands of the system, cluttered with cynical authority figures and unscrupulous inmates, who will turn in anyone to shorten their own sentences. In the book, he tried to mollify himself by denying in his mind and to the jury his part in the murder. While in prison he writes everything in his journal as a screenplay to keep his sanity. If you believe your employer is violating labor laws, the state labor agency is the place to go. At the end of the novel monster, by walter dean myers, many different things happen. Steve imagines himself writing about the crime, but he doesnt want to have it in his mind anymore than the jurors might want to have the pictures in theirs. I kept on wondering and questioning is steve was guilty or not.
Written in a unique format with a compelling storyline, monster is guaranteed to engage teen readers. Apr 21, 1999 i give monster a rate of 5 stars because this book is such an amazing book. The primary change in monster is how steve views himself. His neighborhood was an honesttogoodness thugathon. Steve must be viewed as innocent until proven guilty. Like the jurors, the reader has to weigh the evidence and decide whether steve is innocent or guilty and if he is guilty, of what exactly. We think that steve harmon is innocent because there is not enough evidence to prove he is guilty, he is very certain and stuck with trying to prove that that he was not there when the crime was committed and finally because the other people on trial were using him to get a shorter sentence. Steve s greatest conflict is not really the trial itself, though its certainly stressful and difficult. Monster is a story about a 16year old named steve harmon. Walter dean myers monster guilty until proven innocent monster is an example of what patty campbell would call a landmark book. Again, we really do not know if he is innocent or guilty.
Texts such as these encourage readers to interact with the text and with one another by employing a variety of devices, among them ambiguity campbell 1 because it is told through the eyes of steve. He fights his worst battles in his head, as he tries to figure out if hes truly a monster. I think that monster is a good title for the book but im not sure if its totally appropriate. Though theres only one of him in his screenplay, steve plays quite a few roles in the novel. Printz award in 2000, and was named a coretta scott king award honor the same year the book uses a mixture of a thirdperson screenplay and a firstperson. And teens will appreciate debating whether steve s guilty or not, and related issues, such as the fairness of our judicial. After hearing their complaint, pilate found no fault in him. The two guards that were standing behind steve back away from him.
Is steve really a monster in walter dean myers novel monster. Steve jacksons research for his book monster must have been exhausting. Why is steve innocent in the book monster by walter dean. Well lets look at the book page 147 to 148 steves mother says and i quote no matter what anybody says, i know youre innocent and i love you very much. Monster guilt and innocence presentation by steve harmon on. Even in the middle of the novel steve still thinks he is not guilty and not a bas person but know he has to take responsibility for his actions. Perhaps, it is the authors strength in description that leaves us in the middle. For example, if the employee is being deprived of overtime, he or she should make a complaint with the labor department of the state where the employee works, says john r. Evans testifies that steve was part of the robbery team, acting as a lookout man. Examine the evidence with a worksheet based on monster by walter dean myers. In this book a young man named steve harmon had been put in jail because he supposably killed a man that worked in a drug store.
The innocent makes life magazines life 5 list as another twistfilled triumph. The monster in him is the struggle between his innocence and guilt. A guard tells both king and steve that a verdict is awaiting them. Obrien, who has worked on employeremployee matters in private practice for more than 35 years. Is steve, a gifted wouldbe harlem filmmaker from a loving family, really guilty of this horrific crime. There is not a large amount of scientific evidence in the case against steve. The subject of this book is thomas luther, a complicated and sociopathic man who raped, assaulted, and sometimes killed a series of women between colorado and west virginia. Students find this question difficult to answer and intriguing to debate. The sanhedrin desired the crucifixion of jesus and brought their accusations to pilate. Ghost of the innocent man, a fine debut effort by bostonarea freelance journalist benjamin rachlin, and surviving justice, also fine and edited by the writer dave eggers and the executive director of the life after exoneration program, lola vollen both founders of the voice of witness publishing endeavor examine, from an intimate groundseye view, instances of. The character of steve harmon in monster from litcharts the. Walter dean myers monster guilty until proven innocent. Lovely bones essay in alice sebolds the lovely bones, the theme revolves around the experience of grief, loss, and acceptance.
Steve is wrongfully arrested, and spends time in jail awaiting his verdict, which he is found innocent for after a long trial. And teens will appreciate debating whether steves guilty or not, and related issues, such as the fairness of our judicial system. Was steve guilty or innocent in the book monster answers. For example, bolden planned to use the drugstore intel for himself, but zinzi decided to use it first. Thats the end of monster the film, folks, but not the end for steve. Twentyfive years to life in prisonthats the sentence facing our main man, steve harmon. He describes events spanning from 1982 to 1998 in convincing detail. The book begins with him in jail waiting for his trial to start. In 1985, avery was convicted of raping a woman in manitowoc county in wisconsin. This is undoubtedly due to myers ability to capture the complex character and feelings of steve and reveal the flaws in a criminal justice system which relies on the dehumanization of the accused.
Are these feelings of being a monster based on the truth that he did passively signal the allclear to the. For example, i did not care for hearing what the witnesses or about the stage directions. For example, steve lies to himself frequently in order to hold onto a sense of hope. Monster guilt and innocence presentation by steve harmon. Monster by walter dean myers monster is the story about a 16 year old black boy named steve harmon from harlem. The book monster by walter dean myers, is about teenager steve harmon who has a gift for screen play writing. Opinion innocent but still guilty the new york times. A distance down the track a train carrying 50 passengers approaches at top speed. In walter dean myers monster, steve harmon the defendant in the trial is being charged. Printz award in 2000, and was named a coretta scott king award honor the same year. Examines how steve harmon from walter dean myers book, monster, is guilty of felony murder.
697 209 1301 674 1499 1065 348 256 626 639 511 303 159 1254 611 341 1094 202 152 12 70 24 29 835 532 1047 911 496 875 1373